Last week at Council, at the end of a discussion on the City's flag policy, I made a comment that, although this was not something I expected to resonate, I felt that we should be wary of flyng the flag of any country that is not a democracy. Of course, I was thinking specifically of China, when I made the comment. That is the dictatorship that Kamloops has more formal ties with. However, I did not mention China specifically, I don't think, not really wanting to make waves. With China's star acsendant in the global economy, making friends in that incredible country is almost the holy grail for government and business alike.
In the break, Michelle Young ( veteran reporter with the Kamloops Daily News) asked me to elaborate on my comments. And, in the course of that conversation, my feelings about the lack of democracy in China and my squeamishness with the City's relationship with the Chinese city of Changping came out.
I want to make it clear that I think the China, as a whole, is an amazing and accomplished society. I have met many people from China and found them, the vast majority, wonderful people.
I just have a major issue when minorities, those who are different, those who disagree with the powers that be, are prohibited from and persecuted for being who they are. By their own government.
Michelle wrote an article entitled something like "Singh pleased Chinese flag not flying at City Hall". And Mel Rothenburger, editor of the Daily News, wrote an editorial saying that I was naive - and that the more we interact with China, the more democratic it might become.
We shouldn't give the impression that China has everything to offer us
and we have nothing to offer them. I am a little skeptical of trickle
down democracy.
I don't think I'm naive at all. Focusing on the flag - which is not just the flag of a government, but perhaps also the flag of the people - might not have been the wisest move. But, I do feel strongly that we need to create a space to talk to Chinese government officals about democracy and human rights - not to lecture them, but to have a genuine conversation (after all, we also have our flaws in this regard).
And, if they are not willing to have this conversation, I say lets continue to welcome Chinese people to our community, but not engage in formal partnerships with Chinese cities.